Showing posts with label manchester united. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manchester united. Show all posts

6.2.10

Manchester United Vs Porstmouth | Rooney penalty shout


Description of incident: With the score still at nil-nil, Rooney swiveled with the ball inside the Portsmouth area. The turn blocked off Piquionne's approach and Rooney went tumbling over the ball when Frenchman reached him. The ref waved play on despite Rooney's appeal.

Date of Game: Saturday 6th February 2010

Home Team: Manchester United | Away Team: Portsmouth

Referee: Lee Mason | Linesman: Jake Collin & Paul Thompson

Decision Type: Penalty | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 4/5

Affect on Result: None | Winner: Portsmouth | Loser: Manchester United

Players Involved: Wayne Rooney (Man Utd) & Frederic Piquionne (Porstmouth)

Summary: It was a wonderful turn by Rooney, confusing everyone around him. At first glance it looked as though Piquionne had maybe applied the brakes too late and giving a penalty would have been harsh however, video replays clearly show that he pushed the United striker in the back. The ref got this one wrong, although it had no affect on the result, it should have been a penalty.



Cheers,
WB


1.2.10

Arsenal Vs Manchester United | Clean sheet


Date of Game: Sunday 31st January 2010

Home Team: Arsenal | Away Team: Manchester United

Referee: Chris Foy | Linesman: Dave Bryan & Bob Pollock

Summary: A clean sheet for Foy. No major refereeing incidents, which is unusual for such an important, high profile game. I watched it with an Arsenal fan and he felt dissapointed with the referee but I think this was more about the dissapointment of the way Arsenal performed than anything else, and there was certainly no controversial refereeing decisions directly leading to the game's defining moments.

View full match highlights

Cheers,
WB


24.1.10

Manchester United Vs Hull City | Ref misses Ferdinand elbow on Fagan


Description of incident: As Hull were preparing to swing a cross in from the right wing, all eyes were on the ball. Tussling for space on the edge of the Man Utd area, Ferdinand & Fagan came together resulting in Fagan dropping to the ground. Although the ref was only yards away he saw nothing and gave nothing.

Date of Game: Saturday 23rd January 2010

Home Team: Manchester United | Away Team: Hull City

Referee: Steve Bennett | Linesman: Bob Pollock & Andy Garratt

Decision Type: Red card | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 5/5

Affect on Result: It would have reduced United to ten men with the score still at 1-0 but I'm not sure toothless Hull would have stopped the rampant Rooney even with an extra man | Winner: Man Utd | Loser: Hull

Players Involved: Rio Ferdinand (Manchester United) & Craig Fagan (Hull City)

Summary: Video replays clearly show that Rio Ferdinand threw an arm elbow first into Fagan's face. It was a disgraceful action by the Manchester United captain and deserved an instant red card. But the incident was only captured on one TV camera, which gives an idea of how 'off the ball' it really was. Ferdinand lost control & lashed out but the referee cannot be expected to see everything. Maybe the linesman should have seen something but even that I feel would be a harsh comment. Either way, it was a wrong decision - but hopefully Ferdinand will not escape punishment as his shocking behaviour has to warrant review by the Premier League. Let's hope the referee does not* reference it in his match report.

Cheers,
WB

*If Steve Bennett references the clash involving Ferdinand in his match report, the Premier League will be bound by their own rules to not review the video evidence. This is because they do not want to re-referee incidents - so if the ref does not consider an offense to have occurred, the Premier League back his decision.


16.1.10

Manchester United Vs Burnley | Diouf goal ruled onside


Description of incident: Late in the game, Valencia launched a pass from deep inside his own half which Diouf ran onto to put away Man Utd's third goal. Diouf ruled onside.

Date of Game: Saturday 16th January 2010

Home Team: Manchester United | Away Team: Burnley

Referee: Lee Probert | Linesman: David Richardson & Robert Madley

Decision Type: Offside | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 4/5

Affect on Result: N/A | Winner: Manchester United | Loser: Burnley

Players Involved: Mame Diouf, Antonio Valencia (Man Utd) & Michael Duff (Burnley)

Summary: Another difficult offside decision that the referee got right. It was really tight, even with the benefit of video replays but Duff was just about playing Diouf onside.

Cheers,
WB


10.1.10

Birmingham City Vs Manchester United | Fletcher sending off


Description of incident: Fletcher was sent off for two bookable offenses. The first was for a tackle from behind on Bowyer. The second for a trip on Jerome.

Date of Game: Saturday 9th January 2010

Home Team: Birmingham City | Away Team: Manchester United

Referee: Mark Clattenburg| Linesman: John Flynn & Paul Simpson

Decision Type: Red card | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 2/5

Affect on Result: Arguably none, potentially denying United an extra man in the final push and obviously in games to come when Fletcher will be banned. | Winner: Birmingham City | Loser: Manchester United

Players Involved: Darren Fletcher (Man Utd), Lee Bowyer & Cameron Jerome (Birmingham)

Summary: The first yellow was an obvious one. Fletcher came straight through the back of Bowyer - right decision. The second was definitely not a yellow card offense. Fletcher was stretching for the ball and barely caught Jerome, it wasn't a dangerous tackle, he had little time withdraw his leg from the tackle due to being off balance and it was a clear attempt for the ball.

Cheers,
WB


Birmingham City Vs Manchester United | Scott Dann own goal


Description of incident: After a quick game of pinball inside the Birmingham penalty area, the ball dropped to Evra on the left hand side of the box. He drilled it across goal towards Park, Scholes and Rooney but Dann stretched to reach the ball before all of them unfortunately diverting it into his own net in the process.

Date of Game: Saturday 9th January 2010

Home Team: Birmingham City | Away Team: Manchester United

Referee: Mark Clattenburg | Linesman: John Flynn & Paul Simpson

Decision Type: Offside | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 4/5

Affect on Result: N/A | Winner: Manchester United | Loser: Birmingham City

Players Involved: Patrice Evra, Ji-Sung Park, Paul Scholes, Wayne Rooney (Man Utd) & Scott Dann (Birmingham)

Summary: There was the suggestion by Mark Lawrenson on Match of the Day that because it was an own goal, it no longer becomes an offside decision. And, allegedly, this was also Mark Clattenburg's view. This is a ridiculous argument as Scott Dann only put it in his own net due to the presence of the 3 Man Utd players. The reason allowing the goal is the right decision is that no Man Utd player was offside anyway (Ridgewell was playing them on). Alex McCleish may have been right when he said it was the right decision, wrong reasons. However, whatever the reason it was the right decision to over-rule the linesman's offside flag.

Cheers,
WB


Birmingham City Vs Manchester United | Park penalty shout


Description of incident: Trying to find space for a shot, Park raced past Carr inside the Birmingham penalty area and went tumbling as the two players came together.

Date of Game: Saturday 9th January 2010

Home Team: Birmingham City | Away Team: Manchester United

Referee: Mark Clattenburg | Linesman: John Flynn & Paul Simpson

Decision Type: Penalty | Verdict: | Decision Difficulty: 1/5

Affect on Result: N/A | Winner: Birmingham City | Loser: Manchester United

Players Involved: Ji-Sung Park (Man Utd) & Stephen Carr (Birmingham)

Summary: Easy decision. No penalty. Enough said.

Cheers,
WB